The story about a “buried secret” in the garden of Savannah Guthrie’s sister is very likely not a real news report. There are several strong signs it’s a fabricated or misleading viral article.
Key problems with the story
1. No confirmation from major news outlets
A disappearance involving the mother of a nationally known TV host would be major news. Yet outlets such as NBC News, CNN, or The New York Times have no verified reports about this alleged case.
2. Vague “sources” and missing evidence
The article repeatedly uses phrases like:
-
“sources close to the investigation”
-
“reports circulating online”
-
“allegedly found”
But it never provides official statements from the Federal Bureau of Investigation or the Pima County Sheriff’s Department confirming the claims.
3. Clickbait structure
The page includes many unrelated ads (nail fungus cures, plumbing tricks, parasites, etc.). That layout is typical of clickbait websites that generate revenue from viral stories.
4. Real names used in fictional scenarios
Public figures like Savannah Guthrie are sometimes used in fabricated stories because recognizable names attract clicks.
✅ Bottom line:
There is no reliable evidence that Nancy Guthrie was kidnapped or that investigators found buried evidence in her daughter’s garden. The story appears to be sensationalized or entirely fictional.