Amid the nationwide concern over Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance, a darker story emerged: Derrick Callella’s arrest in Hawthorne, California, exposes how some exploit tragedy for profit. Callella, a former Los Angeles County employee with a history of financial crimes, allegedly sent fake ransom messages to Nancy’s family via VOIP, referencing Bitcoin to mimic the real ransom demand. He had no connection to Nancy’s actual abduction; his goal was to see if the family would respond.
Federal authorities charged him with grand theft and fraudulent communications, noting this behavior mirrors his prior schemes, including a 2025 unemployment benefits fraud. While the arrest signals accountability, it brings no relief to the Guthrie family, who remain focused on obtaining proof of life for Nancy.
The FBI emphasized that Callella’s actions are distinct from the ongoing investigation into Nancy’s disappearance, which remains a top priority. The $50,000 reward for information leading to her recovery is still active. The case highlights the danger of opportunists exploiting grief in the digital age, but authorities promise to pursue both hoaxers and real perpetrators with equal rigor.
For now, the family waits in Tucson, hoping the next breakthrough brings Nancy home.