Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping – Key Timeline & Evidence
At 1:47 a.m. on February 1, 2026, Nancy Guthrie’s doorbell camera went dark. A masked intruder wearing gloves, dark clothing, and a backpack approached, a gun in a holster at their waist.
Twenty-five minutes later, motion was detected but no footage saved. At 2:28 a.m., Nancy’s pacemaker lost connection, suggesting she was moved from her home. Blood was later found on the porch; her phone and medication remained inside.
Nancy, 84, was a retired teacher known for her routine and faith. The previous evening had been normal—dinner and board games with her daughter Annie.
FBI recovered residual Nest camera data eight days later, showing the intruder deliberately covering the camera, using plants to block its view, and working with methodical but imperfect execution. Experts noted the unusual holster placement suggested inexperience.
On February 3, ransom emails demanded $6 million in Bitcoin, with accurate details of Nancy’s attire. Several hoax-related arrests were made, but the authenticity of the original demand remains unconfirmed.
Investigators have released stills and video clips; the masked figure’s gait, backpack, and firearm placement are key leads. Neighborhood canvassing, forensic analysis, drones, and search teams continue. Cell tower, blockchain, and pacemaker data are under review.
Theories include a perpetrator familiar with Nancy, a targeted crime for wealth, or opportunistic ransom exploitation. Savannah Guthrie and siblings have publicly pleaded for her safe return; a $50,000 reward remains.
Nancy disappeared from her Catalina Foothills home in the early hours of February 1. Evidence confirms a masked intruder, blood on the porch, and a critical removal timeframe. Law enforcement continues to pursue all leads.
The footage exists. The timeline is clear. Someone knows who the intruder is.